Insight

Administration’s Fall 2015 Regulatory Agenda Imposes $118 Billion in Costs

The biannual tradition of delaying the release of the nation’s regulatory agenda ended last week with the formal publication of the Unified Agenda. An American Action Forum (AAF) review of the data found at least $118 billion in planned regulatory costs.

Once again, there are few surprises in the regulatory agenda. The administration listed 22 new “economically significant” regulations, up from 18 in the previous agenda. It appears the administration wants to avoid the rush of “midnight regulation,” as the next three months will be busy. If all of the rules are released during the next quarter as planned, costs could reach $33 billion. Notable rulemakings during that period include: the renewable fuels standard, workplace silica rules, Artic drilling regulations, and the revision of nutritional labels.

The early flurry of activity next year could be in response to fears that the Congressional Review Act (CRA) could be used to rescind some rules in 2017. The later the administration publishes significant rulemakings in 2016, the more likely Congress and the next president will be able to repeal those rules. It’s also notable that there are few significant rulemakings scheduled for November or December next year, the traditional “midnight” period.

In fact, some rules were actually moved out of this “midnight” period earlier in the year. Despite the narrative that regulations are always being delayed, several rules are being expedited, at least compared to previous schedules. For example, GHG standards for trucks was initially set for final publication in January, 2017; that has been moved up to July 2016. Silica standards for workers did not have a firm deadline, but the administration now targets February, 2016 for a final rule. Finally, revised nutritional labels also received an expedited timeframe for completion.

Below, there are approximately 40 notable rulemakings and their scheduled publication dates.

November 2015

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

HHS

Final

Regulation on the Sale of Tobacco Products

0910-AG38

$1,010

HUD

Proposed

Smoke-Free Public Housing

2577-AC97

$212

HHS

Final

Covered Outpatient Drugs

0938-AQ41

$104

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Warm Air Furnaces

1904-AD11

$62

Energy

Proposed

Conservation Standards: Central Air Conditioners

1904-AD37

December 2015

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Large Commercial A/C

1904-AC95

$8,800

Treasury

Final

Assessment of Fees for Large Banks

1505-AC42

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Hearth Products

1904-AD35

$1,004

EPA

Final

Renewable Fuels Standard

2060-AS22

$676

January-February 2016

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Gas Furnaces

1904-AD20

$12,270

DOL

Final

Exposure to Crystalline Silica

1218-AB70

$6,524

DOL

Final

Unified and Combined State Plans

1205-AB74

$1,471

Interior

Final

Arctic Drilling Regulations

1082-AA00

$1,324

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Boilers

1904-AC88

$540

DHS

Final

F-1 Nonimmigrant Students

1653-AA72

$503

DOJ

Final

Implementation of ADA Amendments

1190-AA59

$451

DHS

Final

Worker Identification Credential

1625-AB21

$186.1

DOL

Proposed

Paid Sick Leave for Contractors

1235-AA13

 

March 2016

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

HHS

Final

Revision of Nutrition Labels

0910-AF22

$2,008

HHS

Final

Serving Sizes of Foods

0910-AF23

$2,008

DOT

Final

Commercial Driver’s License Clearinghouse

2126-AB18

$1,634

CFPB

Final

Requirements for Prepaid Cards

3170-AA22

$17

DOL

Final

Persuader Agreements

1245-AA03

 

April 2016

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Ovens

1904-AD15

$600

HHS

Final

Sanitary Transportation of Human and Animal Food

0910-AG98

$179

DOL

Final

Personal Fall Protection Systems

1218-AB80

$173.2

HHS

Final

Medicaid, CHIP, and Managed Care

0938-AS25

$111

June 2016

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

HHS

Final

Head Start Performance Standards

0970-AC63

$8,343

HHS

Final

Nondiscrimination: Health Programs

0945-AA02

$939

EPA

Final

Emissions Standards for Fracking

2060-AS30

$420

July-August 2016

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

EPA

Proposed

Phase 2: GHG Standards for Heavy-Duty Engines, Vehicles

2060-AS16

$31,100

Energy

Final

Conservation Standards: Dishwashers

1904-AD24

$7,100

DOL

Final

Overtime Exemptions

1235-AA11

$2,029

September-October 2016

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

HHS

Final

Protection of Human Subjects

0937-AA02

$13,342

HHS

Final

Requirements for Long-Term Care

0938-AR61

$3,018

DOJ

Final

ADA Guidelines for Passenger Vessels

3014-AA11

$1,088

SEC

Final

Investment Company Modernization

3235-AL42

$989

SEC

Final

Standards for Covered Clearing Agencies

3235-AL48

$225

SEC

Final

Rules for Security Swap Dealers

3235-AL12

$210

Long-Term

Agency

Rule Stage

Rule

RIN

Cost (in millions)

DOL

Final

Conflict of Interest-Fiduciary

1210-AB32

$5,700

HHS

Final

Requirements for Discharge Plans

0938-AS59

$1,895

EPA

Final

Formaldehyde Emissions Standards for Composite Wood Products

2070-AJ92

$512

Possible Cost: $118 Billion

The $118 billion estimate contains just 38 monetized figures and an incredible amount of uncertainty. The public does not know the cost of proposed rulemakings not yet published, nor the countless other rules that will be final next year, but were excluded from this agenda. Final costs could balloon or diminish significantly compared to earlier versions.

The administration’s time in office is coming to a close and there appears to be an effort to publish final rules during the first quarter of next year. As rulemaking timelines inch toward the end of 2016, lawmakers in the next Congress could take aim at these “midnight” regulations.

Disclaimer